The Roundtree Amagansett

We had such a lovely early Spring long weekend stay at The Roundtree. The location is ideal if you are exploring The Hamptons- it’s a quick drive to Southampton or Sag Harbor. I can only imagine how wonderful a stay during the summer would be- the grounds are gorgeous and our room was spacious and well laid out. I loved the special touch of snacks and beverage being always available. We had breakfast delivered to the room each morning and were pleased by the freshness and variety offered. Would happily stay again!

The service was beyond incredible. The hospitality, the landscaping, the peaceful environment, and not to mention the serene atmosphere that they created. The staff was unbelievably welcoming and even extended the hours of the fire pit to accommodate my partner and I coming back from a late dinner. I'd give the place a 10 rating if I could because not only did they make everyone feel welcome, they proved it with the way they extended their services beyond the stay. Can't wait to visit again next year

We stayed at The Roundtree during the off-season, when the roses are resting and the crowds mercifully thinned. The garden is charming complete with a fire pit that encourages conversation and contemplation and the staff are warm and attentive without being cloying. In short, one feels pleasantly looked after. The rooms, at first glance, are a visual treat: tasteful finishes, handsome lighting, and the sort of curated minimalism that whispers “Hamptons” rather than shouts it. But alas, beneath the surface polish, the structure reveals its secrets. The walls and floors are, to put it kindly, more symbolic than structural. One hears every footfall, door click, and muffled midnight snack discussion from next door with alarming clarity. At times, it felt less like a hotel room and more like being cast in a radio play with the guests on either side. For the price point, one hopes for better soundproofing and sturdier bones beneath the pretty facade. A future renovation that invests less in sconces and more in silence would be most welcome. Still, a lovely setting and a fine stay just bring your own white noise machine and a sense of humor